Waadaa Collage
Interviews

‘ICJ verdict will give Rohingya moral strength, but repatriation won’t start overnight’: RRRC Mizanur Rahman

Cox’s Bazar refugee commissioner says a ruling for The Gambia would help repatriation and give Bangladesh a new diplomatic tool, but implementation through the UN Security Council may be slow

Mohammad Azharuzzaman

The International Court of Justice (ICJ), the UN’s principal judicial organ, will deliver its judgment on Thursday in the genocide case The Gambia brought against Myanmar over the persecution of the Rohingya.

The court sits in the Peace Palace in The Hague, the Netherlands.

The Gambia filed the case in 2019 under the 1948 Genocide Convention. After a long legal process, the court finished hearing the parties in January this year.

What would the Rohingya gain if genocide is established, and how far could Bangladesh, which shelters them, benefit?

Ahead of the ruling, Daily Waadaa spoke to Mohammed Mizanur Rahman, the Refugee Relief and Repatriation Commissioner (RRRC) at Cox’s Bazar.

Daily Waadaa: The Gambia filed this genocide case against Myanmar in 2019, under the Genocide Convention 1948. After a long legal process, the hearings ended in January this year, and the ICJ is about to give its judgment. As the commissioner in charge of Rohingya repatriation, what would you say: if genocide is established in The Gambia’s favour, how much will the Rohingya gain?

Mizanur Rahman: If the verdict goes in favour of The Gambia, meaning in favour of the Rohingya, it will certainly be a big achievement. That does not mean repatriation will begin the day after the verdict. I see it as a long-term impact. I can say it will give the Rohingya moral strength.

They are old inhabitants of Myanmar. They and their ancestors have lived there for hundreds of years. If the world’s top court recognises the oppression and injustice done to them, or rules in their favour, that is certainly very important.

I believe universities will study it in future. Law departments, international law and genocide studies will include this judgment, and countries will surely shape their policies around it.

DW: But how much will be implemented? And Bangladesh is carrying the burden of the Rohingya as a country. If the ruling goes in their favour, will Bangladesh benefit?

MR: I have doubts about how far the ruling’s implications will go. But since this is a UN court, the judgment will go to the Security Council. The world’s biggest powers will discuss it there, and that will certainly have an effect on Myanmar, on the present government or the de facto authorities who are still oppressing the Rohingya.

The other point is that this matters a great deal for Bangladesh. We will be able to engage with Myanmar formally, with a document in hand, saying that the International Court of Justice has said these things in favour of the Rohingya, things Myanmar has been denying. Citing the court, Bangladesh gets another tool, another opening, for diplomatic engagement.

DW: You mentioned the Security Council. In the Security Council and other UN bodies, many countries have voted in favour of Myanmar on the persecution, torture and genocide of the Rohingya. If the ruling comes in favour of the Rohingya, could their positions change?

MR: I am not in a position to comment on that. But this is a judgment of the International Court of Justice, and there is no appeal against it. So there is no room to reject the ruling.

That does not mean those who earlier vetoed votes on the Rohingya or stood with Myanmar will be unable to stand against the Rohingya once the ruling is in their favour. They may delay implementation or raise various procedural points. But there is no scope to deny the ruling.

DW: What kind of ruling will this be? In ordinary courts, victims receive compensation and offenders are punished.

MR: I don’t know what the ruling will be. But whatever it is, it has to be implemented through the Security Council. Once it goes there, there could be delays over implementation, discussion of procedure, and diplomacy.

If the ruling is in The Gambia’s favour, it will be a victory. It will be a victory for the people who have been subjected to genocide by the Myanmar military and individuals, and a victory for the whole of mankind. I think it will send a message to everyone.

DW: Does Bangladesh have any plan for immediate steps once the ruling comes?

MR: At our level, in Cox’s Bazar, we can mobilise the Rohingya community on what they can and cannot do in future. They are already doing this. They are holding webinars and connecting with their diaspora internationally.

If the ruling goes in their favour, it will lift their morale. We can use that for repatriation. It can create a strong motivation for return. It will strengthen their moral resolve, because they will see that world opinion and the world’s justice system stand with them as a persecuted people. That can build public awareness among them about repatriation, and we can use it.

Our Foreign Ministry will surely engage in diplomacy with the international community and, of course, with the counterpart, Myanmar.

DW: International partners working with the Rohingya: can they draw strength from this ruling?

MR: Yes. The issue will come back before the whole world, and in a strong way. So it will definitely create a focus, which UN agencies, international NGOs and NGOs can use, especially for fundraising and for education, so that they can stand beside this persecuted population.

I think the most important thing is that, whatever the ruling, there will be a definition of the Rohingya in it: who they are, where their country is, and where their ancestors lived. That definition matters a great deal, because this is essentially identity politics. It will create legal accountability and an identity for them.

I believe the Rohingya will get ground beneath their feet. They have been made stateless, and there has been a conspiracy to erase their identity. The International Court of Justice will make a statement on who they are. I believe that will be very important.

PM instructs MPs to return to constituencies to counter banned AL activities

Former interim advisers condemn transnational violent attacks by banned AL, urge UK to prosecute perpetrators

Rohingya pin hopes on November 19 ICJ ruling for justice over genocide

Govt approves 16 development projects worth Tk33,298cr

‘Something other than a merger could happen’ as BB to put Padma Bank under resolution