The scales of justice, the weight of waiting Waadaa Collage
Law & Order

A year after Hasina’s death sentence, the questions the verdict did not settle

Digital evidence and testimony from a former police chief shaped the prosecution’s case. A year later, victims’ families await enforcement of the verdict as prosecutors prepare for an appeal

Md Zaker Hossain

A year after ousted Prime Minister Sheikh Hasina was sentenced to death for crimes against humanity during the July-August 2024 uprising, victims’ families are still waiting for the verdict to be enforced.

The International Crimes Tribunal delivered its judgment on November 17, 2025, convicting Hasina, former Home Minister Asaduzzaman Khan Kamal and former Inspector General of Police Chowdhury Abdullah Al-Mamun over killings and other crimes committed during the uprising.

But questions remain over the appeal proceedings, the enforcement of the sentences and the return of Hasina and Kamal, who remain outside Bangladesh.

Former Chief Prosecutor Tajul Islam has called for a speedy disposal of the appeals, warning that delays could create legal complications.

Current Chief Prosecutor Md Aminul Islam said there was no immediate need for an appeal hearing. He expects proceedings to begin in January or February 2027.

For families of those killed and injured during the uprising, the delay has added to concerns over security and accountability.

Khokon Chandra Barman, the first witness to testify against Hasina, suffered severe facial injuries from police gunfire during the uprising.

“I am alive, yet half-dead,” he told Daily Waadaa by phone on November 15.

“I want the government to enforce the punishment handed down to the offender. If killer Hasina’s death sentence is not carried out, she will return to the country and resume the killings if she gets the opportunity.”

Khokon said he was not afraid of announcements about the Awami League's return but feared for his family's safety.

“I am not afraid of the announcement that Awami terrorists will return. However, my family is living in insecurity.”

Shahriar Khan Palash, whose son Anas was killed during the uprising, expressed similar concerns.

“I testified before the tribunal seeking justice for my son’s murder. But I will not find peace of mind until Hasina’s sentence is carried out,” he told Waadaa on Sunday night.

“As her sentence has not been enforced, she is threatening to return to the country and take revenge. My family has been mentally shattered after losing our child. On top of that, we are terrified by her threats to return!”

Anas’ mother, Sanjida Khan, questioned the progress of reforms promised after the uprising.

“The reasons for which the martyrs sacrificed their lives, and for which thousands of people were injured and left disabled, have not been realised,” she said.

She cited police and judicial reforms and the commission on enforced disappearances among her concerns.

Sanjida also questioned the three-year sentence handed to police constable Sujan Mia over her son's killing.

She contrasted the treatment of former military intelligence official Ziaul Ahsan, who faces allegations involving enforced disappearances and killings, with that of July activist Ayas during court appearances.

“Just look at how Ziaul Ahsan, an accused in hundreds of enforced disappearance and murder cases, is brought before the court wearing sunglasses, like a Nawab, while July activist Ayas is brought to court wearing a helmet!”

Two charges, three sentences

On November 17, 2025, International Crimes Tribunal-1 sentenced Hasina and Kamal to death on one charge and imprisonment until death on another.

Al-Mamun, who admitted his involvement and testified as a state witness, received a five-year prison sentence.

The judgment covered two charges involving six incidents during the uprising.

The first charge concerned Hasina's remarks on July 14, alleged comments about hanging protesters during a conversation with the then vice-chancellor of Dhaka University, and the killing of Abu Sayed in Rangpur.

Hasina and Kamal were sentenced to imprisonment until death on that charge.

The second charge concerned orders to deploy drones, helicopters and lethal weapons against protesters, the killing of six people at Chankharpul, the killing of six others in Ashulia and the burning of bodies.

Both were sentenced to death.

The tribunal also ordered the confiscation of Hasina's properties in Bangladesh in favour of the state and directed arrangements for compensation to victims.

Appeal proceedings remain pending

Former Chief Prosecutor Tajul Islam warned that delays in appeal proceedings could allow convicted fugitives to exploit future political or administrative changes.

He called for the appeals to be heard without delay.

Aminul, the current chief prosecutor, said preparations were underway but argued that an immediate hearing was not mandatory.

The prosecution has appealed against the sentence of imprisonment until death, seeking a death sentence on that charge as well.

Speaking to Waadaa on November 14, Aminul said the hearing could take place early next year.

“We will hold the appeal hearing in January or February next year to seek to uphold the death sentence instead of imprisonment until death,” he said.

“I do not think holding the appeal hearing immediately is mandatory. Under the tribunal law, as Sheikh Hasina is a fugitive, she has no opportunity to appeal under the law.”

Abu Hossain, elder brother of Abu Sayed, who was shot dead in Rangpur during the uprising, called for the verdict to be implemented.

“The verdict that has been delivered should be implemented quickly,” he told Waadaa on November 15.

“The prosecution has informed us that it will take time to hold the appeal hearing. We want those responsible for the July crimes to be tried and their sentences implemented.”

He said the delay had caused further concern among victims' families.

“The soul of Abu Sayed will not find peace unless the verdict is implemented. The oppressors could not tolerate the sight of my brother courageously standing with his chest flaring. They shot him and took his life.”

How prosecutors built the case

The prosecution relied on witness testimony, digital recordings, documentary evidence and forensic analysis to establish responsibility for the crackdown.

Prosecutor Barrister Shaikh Mahdi described the judgment as a milestone in international criminal law.

He said the tribunal had applied definitions of crimes against humanity contained in the Rome Statute and incorporated into Bangladesh's International Crimes (Tribunals) Act, 1973.

The tribunal also examined the evidence against standards developed by the international criminal tribunals for the former Yugoslavia and Rwanda, particularly concerning crimes against humanity and superior responsibility.

Prosecutors sought to establish the timing, location, instructions and circumstances of individual incidents by comparing witness accounts with physical and digital evidence.

Witness protection presented another challenge.

Prosecutor SM Tasmirul Islam said securing testimony from victims and witnesses who faced intimidation required extensive preparation.

“The trial of Sheikh Hasina is not merely about determining responsibility for crimes against humanity; it is also a difficult test of restoring people's lost confidence in the justice system,” he told Waadaa.

“Securing the safety of victims and encouraging them to testify in court despite intimidation, alongside the depositions of 54 witnesses and digital and documentary evidence, were among the biggest challenges for the prosecution.”

Recovering and verifying audio evidence

One of the investigation's most demanding tasks involved recovering audio recordings and establishing their authenticity.

Tanvir Hasan Zoha, a tribunal prosecutor and special investigation officer, said investigators faced delays obtaining information from the National Telecommunication Monitoring Centre (NTMC).

Repeated correspondence and reminders were required before investigators could identify relevant hard drives and retrieve information.

The recovered material underwent forensic examination.

“Through digital forensics, open-source intelligence, audio analysis and cross-verification of information from different sources, efforts were made to uncover the actual picture of the incidents,” Zoha said.

Investigators examined the source, collection method, integrity and chain of custody of each recording.

They also sought to establish whether recordings had been edited, identify the individuals involved and verify the timing of conversations.

Zoha said those steps were necessary to establish the admissibility and reliability of the evidence in court.

“It was a prolonged effort to seek the truth with the help of technology, establish the reliability of evidence and contribute to the process of justice.”

Forty-nine witnesses testified

The prosecution listed 54 witnesses in the case against Hasina. Of them, 49 testified before the tribunal delivered its verdict.

They included injured protesters, relatives of those killed, journalists, physicians, police officers, investigators and political figures involved in the uprising.

Among them were Khokon Chandra Barman; Abu Sayed's father, Mokbul Hossain; National Citizen Party Convener Nahid Islam; Daily Amar Desh Editor Dr Mahmudur Rahman; and former IGP Al-Mamun.

Other witnesses included Abdullah Al Imran, who was injured during the uprising; Rina Murmu, an eyewitness to Abu Sayed's killing; and journalist AKM Moinul Haque, who recorded footage of the shooting.

Injured protesters Parveen, Abdus Samad and Naim Shikdar also testified.

Relatives of those killed included Shahina Begum, mother of Sazzad Hossain Sohel; Md Enab Najez Zaki, son of As-Sabur; Rabiul Awal Bhuiyan, brother of Hasan Taim Bhuiyan; and Md Saidur Rahman, grandfather of Anas.

Medical witnesses included Mohammad Hasnat Al Matin, Dr Md Rajibul Islam, who conducted Abu Sayed's autopsy, Mohammad Mahfuzur Rahman and eye specialist Dr Zakia Sultana Neela.

Police officer Md Ashraful Islam, prosecutor and special investigation officer Zoha, and investigation officer Md Alamgir also gave evidence.

Former police chief describes orders from the top

Al-Mamun's testimony provided an account of decision-making within the government and police during the uprising.

After admitting his involvement and becoming a state witness, the former IGP testified about political interference in policing between 2014 and 2024, alleged enforced disappearances and torture, election irregularities and orders to use lethal force against protesters.

He described meetings at the former Home Minister's residence, instructions allegedly issued by Hasina and discussions among senior government and security officials.

Al-Mamun testified that meetings of a core committee monitoring the uprising took place every night at Kamal's residence after July 16, 2024.

At a meeting on July 19, officials proposed detaining protest coordinators.

Al-Mamun claimed he opposed the proposal but that the detentions were subsequently carried out on the Home Minister's instructions.

The former police chief said Kamal called him on July 18 and conveyed an instruction from Hasina to use lethal weapons against protesters.

Al-Mamun said he passed the instruction to senior police officials and that the use of lethal force began that day.

Al-Mamun also described a meeting chaired by Hasina at Ganabhaban on August 4, a day before her government fell.

He said 27 people attended, including the chiefs of the three armed services, the Home Minister, the Law Minister and intelligence officials.

According to his testimony, participants decided to establish resistance at entry points to Dhaka to prevent the planned August 5 “March to Dhaka” programme.

His testimony extended to the 2018 general election.

Al-Mamun alleged that he had advised officials to place 50% of ballot papers in ballot boxes overnight before polling.

He also described the alleged involvement of officials from the administration and law enforcement agencies.

Al-Mamun testified that while serving as director general of the Rapid Action Battalion, he learned about a secret detention facility in Uttara known as the Task Force Interrogation Cell, or TFI Cell.

He alleged that political dissenters were detained and tortured there.

He said he informed Tarique Ahmed Siddique, then security adviser to the Prime Minister, but no action followed.

Al-Mamun acknowledged that he had failed to take appropriate action against abuses during his tenure.

“I am ashamed and remorseful that such grave crimes took place during my tenure,” he told the tribunal.

The first witness and his injuries

Khokon Chandra Barman was shot in the face in Jatrabari on August 5, 2024.

He lost his left eye and suffered extensive injuries to his nose, jaw and face.

Khokon had participated in demonstrations in the Signboard area of Narayanganj on July 18 and 19.

On August 5, he travelled to Dhaka and witnessed casualties from police gunfire in Jatrabari.

According to his testimony, he took shelter behind pillars and drums beneath the Jatrabari flyover when a police officer fired at him.

The bullet struck his face.

He underwent treatment at Mugda Medical College Hospital, Dhaka Medical College Hospital, Mirpur Dental Hospital and the National Institute of Burn and Plastic Surgery.

He was later sent to Russia for advanced treatment and required further surgery.

On August 3, 2025, Khokon became the first witness to testify in the case.

He showed the tribunal his facial injuries, described the shooting and demanded justice for those killed.

Hasina's right to appeal disputed

Law Minister Advocate Md Asaduzzaman said on November 14 that Hasina had no remaining opportunity to appeal her conviction.

Speaking to journalists at an event, he said the special law governing crimes against humanity did not allow the Appellate Division to condone delays in filing appeals.

“There is no provision for condonation of delay in the Appellate Division in cases involving crimes against humanity,” he said.

“The Appellate Division has no legal provision to condone delays in such cases because the special law does not provide for any opportunity to condone them. They themselves enacted that law.”

He also referred to Article 47(3) of the Constitution.

“In the amendment to the Constitution introduced by Sheikh Hasina's father in 1973, it was stated that no person accused or convicted of crimes against humanity could claim fundamental rights. This is a law enacted by them,” he said.

The government's position comes amid renewed discussion in Bangladesh and India over Hasina's possible return.

The Law Minister said Dhaka had completed the legal procedures required to seek her return from India.

He said the decision on whether to send her back now rested with the Indian government.

—

The ‘foreign investor’ from Dubai in Islami Bank was S Alam

Minimum Wages Board schedules third meeting on RMG workers’ wage revision on November 23

Former Dhaka mayor Sayeed Khokon arrested in Baridhara

Nahid blames government for Awami League ‘comeback’ after London attack

AL activists attack NCP supporters after Nahid’s London event, 10 injured