Political movements often inspire hope while some others inspire fear. And then there is the Awami League in Gopalganj, which appears determined to inspire a Monty Python sequel.
On Friday, videos of dozens of men roaming the rain-soaked roads of Gopalganj, brandishing machetes, enormous sickles and, believe it or not, shields, became some of the most wonderfully wondrous images circulating on Bangladesh's social media.
Yes, shields. Actual shields.
The sort of equipment one associates with medieval infantry, Roman legions or an exceptionally enthusiastic historical re-enactment society. The men appeared to have raided an ancient museum, helped themselves to the armoury and marched out to fight an enemy known only to themselves.
There were war cries. There was considerable swagger...or dance like moves. There was a good bit of determination of men convinced that history was about to change direction because they had acquired unusually large agricultural implements.
One might have expected the spectacle to inspire terror, or at least a little apprehension. Instead, much of the social media reaction was ridicule.
And therein lies the problem.
The men had come prepared for battle. Their audience thought they had come for an audition of the wrong kind.
Yet behind this medieval pantomime lies something ‘considerably’ more disturbing. The armed men are not merely playing soldiers. They are participants in a political fight that has already left public buildings including a hospital damaged, police facilities attacked and ordinary life disrupted.
Their imagined enemy is not another armed faction. It is the political reality of Bangladesh itself.
Gopalganj, the ancestral district of Sheikh Hasina, has become the setting for a strange experiment in political denial. Some of the ousted leader's most fervent supporters appear to believe that by turning their home district into a fortress of defiance, they can somehow overturn the verdict of the rest of the country.
It is secession without a declaration and revolution without a remotely plausible plan.
The inspiration, naturally, comes from Sheikh Hasina, the convicted former prime minister whose promised December return has apparently sent sections of her remaining loyalists into a frenzy of anticipation.
The problem is that political promises issued from exile are considerably easier to make than political realities are to rearrange.
And so the faithful have taken to the streets, fighting shadows, hunting imaginary enemies and treating the roads of Gopalganj as though they were the last frontier of a besieged kingdom.
Miguel de Cervantes would have recognised the symptoms immediately. His Don Quixote mistook windmills for giants and charged them with a lance. The Gopalganj variety has upgraded the weaponry but retained the diagnosis.
Where Quixote saw monsters in machinery, these men appear to see an occupying army in the political order that emerged after Hasina's downfall.
The difference is that Cervantes's knight was a harmless romantic for much of his adventure. The modern imitators have been accused of burning homes and damaging public property.
There is something profoundly absurd about a political movement that believes violence against its own neighbourhood constitutes a strategy for national restoration. The Awami League's remaining militants are effectively making war on the place they claim to defend.
And the people paying the price are overwhelmingly those living around them.
One claim circulating on Facebook suggested that the disruption of transport and supplies had pushed the price of an inexpensive cigarette in parts of Gopalganj to three times its normal level.
The claim is unverified, but the political metaphor is irresistible. A movement promising national liberation has apparently reached the stage where its own supporters may struggle to afford a decent smoke…a wartime necessity.
Well, this is not exactly the storming of the Bastille. It is a revolution that has managed to blockade its own corner shop. The grand political struggle eventually arrives at the household budget. And households, unlike political fanatics, tend to notice.
To the Awami League, the larger question is whether anyone in its leadership has considered what all this war cry is supposed to achieve.
The party's activities remain banned under Bangladesh's anti-terrorism legislation. Its leader is in exile. Its organisational machinery has been severely weakened. Its political legitimacy has been devastated by the violence and repression associated with its years in power.
These are real obstacles to any comeback. A battalion of men carrying shields is unlikely to solve them.
Political rehabilitation requires rebuilding public trust, confronting the past, offering a credible programme and persuading people who no longer believe in the party. None of these tasks can be accomplished with an exceptionally long sickle for sure. A shield, also, is an excellent instrument for protecting oneself against an approaching spear. It is rather less effective against public contempt.
The BNP government faces a test though. It must restore order and prosecute those responsible for violence without allowing the response to become indiscriminate punishment.
The easiest way to give a failing insurgent fantasy fresh political oxygen is to turn law enforcement into collective revenge. But Gopalganj's residents are not collectively responsible for the actions of armed loyalists. A district cannot be convicted by association.
The government's challenge is to demonstrate that the state can distinguish between a criminal and a citizen, even when the criminal claims to be fighting for an ousted prime minister.
Don Quixote at least had Sancho Panza, a companion occasionally capable of recognising the difference between fantasy and fact. The Awami League's Gopalganj warriors could use someone similarly practical.
Someone to explain that Bangladesh is not a windmill, that a shield is not a manifesto and that a promised December homecoming is not a substitute for a political future. Until then, the knights of Gopalganj will continue charging at shadows.
And the windmills will continue winning.
—
Faisal Mahmud is the Managing Editor of Daily Waadaa