The popular cliché that ‘if you can’t change the queen, you change yourself’ gave way to newer clichés, drawn as graffiti across the country’s walls during the July Uprising. The Queen was not only changed, but a set of changes was set in motion in politics, economics, international relations, and the conduct of government, as well as among the citizenry.
The question needs to be revisited: the queen melted away; what changed in the nation? Were the graffiti destined to be bound in a book, or disposed of as a national gift? Does the current dispensation still fail to read where real power accrues from? Does the nation still watch a cat-and-mouse game in dealing with crises stemming from social problems?
Are there still class-based discriminations among citizens? Are lies still nurtured and truth shied away from? Do the security forces lament the lack of abuse of force or absence of unlawful orders? Do the media still praise power and not press it to answer for wrongs? Do newspaper headlines reflect real concerns, or do they chase news to deflect toward ulterior political objectives?
Does the judiciary operate purely by law, or does it abuse the fringes of the law to benefit criminals with greater muscle and money power? Will there be a return to the culture of worshipping a leader like God? Will the leader again become bigger than the country? Will the nation see leaders placing their trust in a clan rather than in merit? If the majority of the answers are affirmative, changes haven’t been made to defy virtual threats of the Queen's return.
Questions should emerge by looking at changes either brought to the table with little effect compared to the aspirations of the youth who shed blood in July, or denied to sustain the old system that suits the politics of convenience. The question needs to include whether democracy was achieved in the heart and head of politics or only rubber-stamped under electoral complacency.
Politics, economics, and international relations are in a crisis that cannot be fixed on short notice, against people's patience. Amid the trauma of July's conduct, security forces are walking a tightrope, deciding how to apply force and to what extent to defuse tensions in crisis situations. Both media and social platforms use their own judgment to pick up issues of concern, regardless of whether they warrant attention.
The nation, habituated to being sensitized to issues one after another, keeps rolling in confusion. The government's response to crises is reactive, either by ignoring them as part of conspiracy theories or by having the leader of the house request the combined hands of both benches after a police station or houses of Parliament members are burnt down.
The system of government under the new Bangladesh is running on an old social contract and under the hangover of colonial management. Placement of the most appropriate person in the most appropriate places overnight is difficult given the political reality. A nation polarized on its own identity is pushed further into ideas of sub-nationalism fomented by the leaders in exile across the border in their only stronghold in the country.
The nation understands the difficulties of the current dispensation in declaring a geographic entity as not its own and going punitive like a military junta. The nation also respects the patience of the dispensation in dealing with it as fairly as possible rather than following the trail and techniques of the fascist regime. Therefore, it is not a burden on the people of the country to seek a response from the government alone.
The power that the citizenry has already established over its elected government has enough weight to prompt action from it at the appropriate time and in a civilized manner.
The virtual claims of the Queen's return are a feint, and the anarchy created by her supporters in a particular chunk of territory is not only foolhardiness but also the digging of their own tomb. The Republic 2.0 doesn’t fail to read friend and foe and separate real threats from false alarms. The scar inflicted on its heart by the repressive reign of 17 years is irremovable.
The dream of another repressive reign is impossible, and efforts at reconciliation are beyond question. The spirit of July is irreversible; seeking any legal foundation based on constitutional sense is futile. It was neither a political opponent nor a military ruler, nor a regime-change mechanism that removed the regime in July. It was the power of the people from all walks of life, regardless of their political or religious identity.
Both the current dispensation and the security forces realize that any attempt to facilitate the Queen's return under any regulated scheme would not only fail but also have consequences hard to bear. The Queen melted away; investment behind her from home or abroad is imprudent and a waste of money and time. The train of the Republic 2.0 is on the rails; it will reach its destination with sporadic stops, but not for long. The wind of July was strong, like a twister, blowing away not only the Queen but also her associates, from members of the party to parliament, members of the family to its third generation, oligarchs to the governor of the state bank, and stalwarts of the security forces.
The realization of the poor supporter at home will eventually return, but not the Queen blown away with the wind.
—
Brig Gen AF Jaglul Ahmed, ndc, psc, PhD (Retd), contributes to national dailies.