A legacy in full, remembered in parts Waadaa Collage
Reflections

Everyone claims Bhashani. Few can afford his politics

As Bangladesh marks the 50th death anniversary of Maulana Bhashani, many claim a legacy of him without embracing the political costs that defined his politics

Mahmud Newaz Joy

At Santosh in Tangail Sadar upazila, the wreaths go down in turns.

Last November, the family, the press club, the NAP (Bhashani), the Bhashani Parishad and organisations on the university campus laid theirs separately on the mausoleum. The BNP formed its own national committee for the occasion.

This is the fiftieth year since Maulana Bhashani died, and Bangladesh has changed. A BNP government holds a two-thirds majority, the Awami League he helped found is banned by law, and the Ganges treaty expires on December 12.

Each group at the shrine has a legitimate claim. The Awami League remembers the founder, the BNP invokes Farakka, the left celebrates the peasant leader. But each preserves the Bhashani it can honour without paying a political price. The rest is left out.

He abandoned parties he had built, challenged governments he had helped bring to power and paid for those decisions.

To follow him, as the speeches suggest, means accepting that cost.

The Awami League's claim is the oldest. He founded the Awami Muslim League in 1949 and later pushed to remove 'Muslim' from its name. Mujib, then a young organiser, called him 'Huzur'. Bhashani reminded rally crowds that Mujib had once been among the secretaries working under him.

In February 1969, with Mujib imprisoned, he threatened to march on Dhaka cantonment unless the Agartala case was withdrawn. A Time correspondent credited him, as much as any individual, with igniting that year's uprising. In 1971, he served on the Mujibnagar government's advisory council. This is the Bhashani the party commemorates.

The other Bhashani receives less attention. Within months of independence, he stood at Paltan Maidan and publicly challenged Mujib's policies for the first time since liberation. In May 1973, he fasted for eight days over food shortages and rising prices, as he had done in 1956 for famine victims.

His weekly Haq Katha spared no one and was banned after gaining readers. At a 1974 rally, he blamed the food shortage on the presence of a Hindu minister, a damaging remark his admirers seldom recall. Even August 15, 1975, survives in conflicting accounts: one has him weeping and retreating to his prayer room; another has him welcoming the coup.

The party remembers its patron, but not its critic.

The BNP's claim is strongest when confined to Farakka. Tarique Rahman has called Bhashani an inspiration for democracy, independence and national sovereignty. The sovereignty claim has a history. Farakka was inaugurated in April 1975.

According to Bangladesh's account, India began withdrawing water unilaterally after August, triggering the 1976 crisis. On April 18, 1976, shortly after leaving hospital, Bhashani announced he would lead a long march if India denied Bangladesh its share. Critics dismissed it as a stunt.

On May 16, in his mid-nineties, he addressed a gathering at the Madrasa grounds in Rajshahi before the march proceeded toward Kansat, near the border. In his closing speech, he threatened a boycott of Indian goods unless Delhi responded. The march is regarded as the first popular mobilisation against India over Ganges water.

The military-led government reportedly supported it unofficially. Ziaur Rahman raised the dispute at the UN General Assembly that year and signed the first Ganges agreement in November 1977. The BNP later revived Farakka Day while in opposition.

That claim now faces a test. The 1996 treaty contains no automatic extension clause. Dhaka formally approached Delhi in June and sent a reminder in August. India has yet to respond positively. Delhi says the issue belongs with the Joint Rivers Commission, while Bihar has urged the central government against renewal.

The obstacles lie largely across the border. The 1977 agreement included a guarantee clause, which Dhaka wants restored. Bhashani could demand the barrage's removal. A government invoking his legacy must secure a number and a clause by December 12, or explain why it failed.

The left has the strongest emotional attachment and the weakest organisation. 'The Red Maulana' appeals to those who celebrate a peasant leader, though his title was religious and his education came from Deoband. His party fractured along the Sino-Soviet divide, and his death effectively ended it.

Some followers now seek textbook chapters, official anniversary observances and constitutional recognition, as demanded by the Bhashani Followers' Council. A man who spent his life confronting the state becomes a monument his followers want the state to maintain. One descendant has followed his example of breaking ranks.

Late last year, his grandson Azad Khan Bhashani left the National Citizen Party amid turmoil over its alliance with Jamaat, invoking the anti-hegemonic politics that had attracted him.

The most consequential break is rarely commemorated. On November 12, 1970, a cyclone devastated the coast weeks before Pakistan's first general election. At Paltan on November 23, Bhashani condemned the government's slow response, called for an independent East Pakistan and announced an election boycott.

His withdrawal helped deliver Mujib's Awami League a landslide and deepened his own party's troubles. That was the political cost: a principled withdrawal that surrendered the electoral field to a rival. Those claiming his legacy today have remained in electoral politics, won power, governed or sought to govern.

Following his example would have required the Awami League, while in government, to tolerate the critic whose newspaper it instead banned. It would require the BNP, now governing, to accept public pressure over the Ganges treaty rather than direct that pressure solely at Delhi.

Every political legacy is selective. A party can honour one part of a leader's record without embracing the whole. The Awami League's founding claim is genuine. So is the BNP's connection to Farakka. But the omissions follow a pattern. Each party discards the part of Bhashani's politics that would challenge its own authority.

A governing party cannot easily claim a legacy built on resistance to governments. It can, however, deliver what he demanded and submit to the same scrutiny.

At Santosh today, the wreaths are laid one group at a time. In 2024, his memorabilia there lay neglected for want of official attention. And the Ganges treaty expires on December 12.

--

Mahmud Newaz Joy is a freelance feature writer based in Bangladesh.

London Police investigate ‘violent disorder’ after Nahid Islam event, appeal for CCTV footage

Bangladesh condemns London attack, urges investigation and justice

ACC seeks Interpol Red Notices against Hasina, family; freezes Tk1,062cr, files 24 cases

The ‘foreign investor’ from Dubai in Islami Bank was S Alam

Minimum pay talks: Wage Board visits factory floors to assess workers’ needs, owners’ capacity