A white paper where the figures climb and the logic takes a dive.
A white paper where the figures climb and the logic takes a dive.Waadaa Collage

Awami League-linked white paper faces scrutiny over $112 billion loss claim against interim government

Updated on: 

A forthcoming white paper assessing the economic record of Bangladesh's interim government has drawn criticism over its methodology, with a Canada-based Bangladeshi public policy specialist accusing its authors of conflating economic costs with losses.

The public policy specialist also criticized attributing banking-sector problems inherited from the Awami League government to the administration of Muhammad Yunus.

Galib Ibn Anwarul Azim, who works for the Canadian government now,  raised the objections in a Facebook post, challenging the paper's headline estimate that Bangladesh suffered between $80 billion and $112 billion in economic costs during the 18 months following August 5, 2024.

Galib described the publication as an initiative involving Awami League-aligned economists and researchers. He said one of the authors had been active on Awami League-linked online platforms since the fall of Sheikh Hasina's government.

He also identified Imam Hossain Emon, whom he described as a proponent of "Hasinomics," as the initiative's coordinator, citing the report's acknowledgments section.

His assertions about the political affiliations of those involved are separate from his methodological criticisms and require independent verification.

The paper, titled Counting the Economic Cost: A Whitepaper on Bangladesh under the Yunus-led Interim Regime, names four authors: Mamunur Rashid, Sangita Gazi, Bidit L. Dey and Tashfeen Hussain.

Galib's first objection concerns the distinction between economic costs and losses.

The paper separates losses into three categories: opportunity losses, actual output and asset losses, and cost-differential losses. In Section 2.1, the authors say the categories should be reported separately because combining them would obscure differences in reliability.

Yet the executive summary presents an overall estimate of $80 billion to $112 billion. Galib argued that the presentation contradicted the paper's own methodological warning.

He said the use of "cost" and "loss" as interchangeable terms was another weakness, particularly in a document seeking to quantify economic damage.

The sharpest criticism concerns the treatment of non-performing loans. According to figures Galib cited from the paper, its executive summary assigns between $31.9 billion and $42.1 billion in counted losses to banking and finance.

Another section identifies $28.2 billion in banking-sector losses, making it the largest component of the estimate. Galib questioned why losses associated with previously concealed bad loans should be counted against the Yunus administration when the loans originated under earlier governments.

In a section titled "The NPL Shock as a Manufactured Crisis," the authors compare banking-sector NPL ratios before and after July 2024.

They report that the system-wide average rose from 9.74% during the earlier period to 27% afterward, while the average for private commercial banks increased from 5.40% to 23.63%.

Galib argued that the sharp increase reflected, at least partly, the central bank's efforts to identify previously concealed bad loans rather than the creation of entirely new losses.

Galib also challenged the paper's treatment of mobile financial service provider Nagad. The report devotes a separate section to Bangladesh Bank's intervention in the company in 2024.

It describes the stated reasons for the appointment of an administrator as alleged irregularities and an ownership dispute, but concludes that the actual motivation was political.

Under a table titled "Nagad digital finance suppression," the authors estimate losses of approximately $1.8 billion associated with the intervention.

Galib questioned both the calculation and the absence of discussion about alleged irregularities involving Third Wave, which he identified as being associated with Nagad.

He said he could not find the company's name anywhere in the document.

He also pointed to another instance of inconsistent terminology, with the table listing financial inclusion costs under a heading covering losses.

Galib argued that an assessment of the intervention's economic consequences should account for the regulatory concerns that prompted Bangladesh Bank's action.

The dispute follows the publication of an earlier white paper commissioned by the Yunus administration to examine Bangladesh's economic record under Hasina.

That report, prepared by a 12-member committee headed by economist Debapriya Bhattacharya and submitted on December 1, 2024, estimated that approximately $234 billion had been illicitly transferred abroad between 2009 and 2023.

It also documented alleged corruption in public investment, banking, energy and other sectors. 

—