‘Today, we have recognition’: Rohingya celebrate landmark genocide ruling
As Cyclone Akvan brought rain to the world’s largest refugee camp in Cox’s Bazar on Thursday, with a more severe weather forecast, Rohingya families gathered around televisions and large screens, waiting to hear whether the world’s highest court would finally recognise the atrocities committed against their community in Myanmar.
Seven years after predominantly Muslim Gambia filed the case, refugees watched from their homes, schools and designated gathering places. Some followed the proceedings on large screens, while others tuned in on televisions and mobile phones.
At Hakimpara High School in Camp 15, 18-year-old Mohammad Rashid had been waiting since midday alongside eight members of his family. They wanted to hear the court’s decision together.
When Judge Yuji Iwasawa delivered the finding that “Myanmar has committed genocide against the Rohingya group in Northern Rakhine State”, Rashid’s family was overcome with emotion. They thanked Allah. Some wept with happiness and relief as news of the verdict spread.
The scene was much the same across the camps as the ruling marked a moment of vindication for a community that has spent years seeking international recognition of the persecution it endured.
“The world knows today about the brutality of the Myanmar military and how the Rohingya community has suffered for so long. Nobody cared about us. Today, we have recognition,” Khin Maung, acting president of the United Council of Rohingya, told Daily Waadaa.
The International Court of Justice (ICJ) found that Myanmar’s security forces had killed thousands of Rohingya civilians, committed widespread sexual violence, perpetrated extreme violence against children and attacked Rohingya fleeing the violence.
Reading the judgment, presiding judge Iwasawa said the only reasonable inference from the evidence was that Myanmar’s security forces had intended to destroy a substantial part of the Rohingya population in northern Rakhine.
The judgment, delivered by a nine-to-six majority, also recognised the Rohingya as a distinct ethnic group, citing their language, culture and shared identity. It found that Myanmar had subjected them to decades of discrimination and that military-sponsored hate speech had helped create an environment conducive to violence.
The court said Myanmar was obligated to provide reparations to the victims, although the amount and form of compensation will be determined at a later stage.
Must translate into accountability for those responsible
For Rohingya refugees, the significance of the ruling extends beyond the courtroom.
Young Rohingya activist Maung Solaiman Shah said the case was about the lives and dignity of a people who had endured decades of persecution, displacement and discrimination.
The proceedings had given survivors an opportunity to have their experiences heard internationally and challenged the impunity that had allowed abuses to continue, he said.
But justice, he warned, could not remain confined to legal pronouncements.
“It must translate into accountability for those responsible, the protection of Rohingya people, the restoration of our rights and citizenship, and the creation of conditions for a safe, dignified and voluntary return to our homeland,” he said.
“We are not asking for sympathy; we are demanding justice.”
The distinction between political recognition and legal acknowledgment is significant.
Nasir Uddin, a professor of anthropology at the University of Chittagong who has written extensively on the Rohingya, said in an earlier interview that “there is a difference between making a political speech and having a legal judgment supporting your claims”.
For decades, Myanmar authorities have denied the Rohingya's identity as a distinct ethnic group, frequently describing them as migrants from Bangladesh. The ICJ's recognition of the community as a protected ethnic group is therefore particularly significant.
The ruling also places Myanmar's responsibility for genocide firmly on the international legal record. Whether it leads to accountability, however, will depend largely on what governments do next.
Richard Horsey, senior adviser for Asia at the International Crisis Group, described the judgment as historic, saying it was the first time the ICJ had found a state responsible for committing genocide.
“The Rohingya have waited nine years to hear a court say this. It will not change their lives quickly, but it puts what was done to them on the legal record, and no amount of denial in Naypyitaw can remove it,” Horsey said.
He cautioned, however, that the court had no means of enforcing its ruling.
“What matters now is whether the governments engaging Naypyitaw are prepared to attach any cost to ignoring it,” he said.
Human Rights Watch (HRW) described the ruling as a long-awaited recognition of Rohingya suffering and urged governments to press Myanmar to comply with the judgment and ensure that refugees could return safely and voluntarily.
John Quinley, director of Fortify Rights, also called on states to take action to hold Myanmar's military accountable in a written statement to Waadaa.
Repatriation must be voluntary, safe and dignified
The hope of returning home was repeatedly voiced across the camps on Thursday.
Ayat Ullah, a young refugee in Camp 15, said many people were happy after hearing the verdict, which had revived their hopes of returning to Myanmar.
Camp 2W head majhi Nur Mohammad said refugees had thanked Allah after hearing the judgment.
“We hope it would help restore their rights and create a path for a safe return to Myanmar,” he told Waadaa.
However, refugees say they cannot return without citizenship, security, freedom of movement and access to education, healthcare and livelihoods. Any repatriation, they insist, must be voluntary, safe and dignified.
Conditions in Rakhine have become more complicated since the refugees fled. The Arakan Army, an ethnic Rakhine armed group fighting Myanmar's military, now controls much of the territory, including areas from which many Rohingya escaped.
Thomas Kean of the International Crisis Group told Waadaa in a detailed interview that the conflict in Myanmar had made repatriation extremely difficult. The Arakan Army would be an essential actor in any future return process, but continued fighting made security guarantees impossible for now.
Horsey also warned that the Arakan Army's treatment of Rohingya would be crucial for those still living in Rakhine. A judgment against Myanmar, by itself, cannot resolve the security and political realities on the ground.
For many refugees in the camps, however, Thursday's judgment offered something they had waited years to hear: an international court acknowledging the crimes committed against their community.
“We urge the international community to continue supporting our long-standing struggle for justice and the restoration of our rights,” said Rohingya leader Syed Ullah.