CPD defends RMG minimum wage analysis, says family size assumptions did not inflate wage estimate
The Centre for Policy Dialogue (CPD) has defended its analysis of the minimum wage for readymade garment (RMG) workers, maintaining that its assumptions on household size and the number of income earners were based on published research and did not artificially inflate its proposed wage estimates.
In a response dated November 22 to observations raised by the Bangladesh Garment Manufacturers and Exporters Association (BGMEA), the think tank said it had considered a median household size of four members and an average of 1.58 income earners per household, drawing on multiple published studies.
CPD said it adopted the median household size to avoid the influence of extreme values in the data. It added that using BGMEA's suggested household size of 3.96, based on the BBS's Sample Vital Statistics (SEDS) 2023 survey, would reduce the poverty-based wage estimate by only Tk 186, from Tk 18,578 to Tk 18,392.
The think tank further noted that the Household Income and Expenditure Survey (HIES) 2022 puts the average household size at 4.18 members in urban areas and 4.26 nationally. Against this backdrop, its assumption of four members was lower than the urban average, contradicting the claim that a larger household size had been used to raise the wage estimate.
CPD also argued that adopting the HIES 2022 average of 1.37 income earners per urban household would actually result in a higher required wage. It stressed that its estimates should be viewed as indicative ranges rather than definitive figures, as they were not based on a large-scale, representative survey.
Responding to BGMEA's questions about the upper poverty line, CPD defended its use of the HIES 2022 upper poverty-line benchmark of Tk 4,922 per capita for urban areas in Dhaka division. It said the figure better captures the cost of living in urban and industrial areas, while an average of rural and urban poverty lines would not be appropriate without reliable data on the geographical distribution of garment workers.
On allegations of double-counting housing costs, CPD said it had excluded house rent from non-food expenditure and tobacco costs from food expenditure before calculating essential household expenses. These included clothing, utilities, education, transport, personal care and communication.
Regarding annual wage increments, CPD pointed out that raising the increment rate from 5% to 9% with effect from December 1, 2024, has increased earnings for existing workers but has not changed the Tk 12,500 entry-level minimum wage applicable to newly recruited workers. The higher increment rate has also increased labour costs for factories, it added.
The think tank explained that its analysis focused on entry-level wages because reliable, grade-specific data on worker productivity and factory costs were unavailable. However, it said the upper boundary of its proposed wage range took into account the industry's financial capacity, production costs, interest rates, export prices and pressure from US tariffs.
CPD also maintained that a proper assessment of the industry's ability to pay would require updated and reliable information on factory operating expenses, product prices and profitability, which is currently lacking.
Concluding its response, the think tank called for a large-scale, scientifically designed survey covering both garment workers and factories to ensure that future minimum wage decisions are based on updated, representative and reliable data. In this case the decision should be made based on the standard according to the labor act 2006, section 141 such as cost of living, cost of production, productivity, inflation and business capacity.