The PEN is mightier than the silence
The PEN is mightier than the silenceWaadaa Collage

PEN Bangladesh’s crisis goes beyond its disputed presidency

Questions about its response to persecuted writers, ties among successive leaders and PEN International’s oversight reveal a deeper struggle over accountability
Updated on: 

In 2025, two rival groups announced two different presidents of PEN Bangladesh, the national affiliate of PEN International, a global organisation dedicated to defending writers and freedom of expression.

One group named former ambassador Mosud Mannan. The other elected academic Shamsad Mortuza. Yet PEN International's publicly available directory continued to identify neither man. Instead, it listed Kazi Anis Ahmed, the former president, with a corporate email address associated with the Gemcon Group as the centre's contact.

More than a year after the rival announcements, the organisation's public records still offered no clear answer to a basic question: Who was authorised to speak for Bangladesh's writers?

The vagueness has exposed deeper questions about PEN Bangladesh's governance, its overlapping political and institutional relationships and its record of defending writers and journalists during Sheikh Hasina's dictatorial rule.

An examination by Daily Waadaa of historical PEN records, election announcements, university documents, contemporary reporting and public statements found discrepancies in the organisation's leadership history and gaps in its publicly documented responses to several prominent cases of censorship and repression.

PEN International has never publicly explained how it assessed the competing leadership claims.

Waadaa twice emailed questions to Michael Altman Rosen-Lupu, PEN International's head of the Asia-Pacific region, and Ross Holder, who previously held that position. Neither responded.

The questions concerned the disputed elections, the centre's leadership, its institutional relationships and the international organisation's oversight responsibilities.

A record of selective interventions

In February 2023, Bangla Academy denied Adarsha Prokashoni a stall at the Ekushey Book Fair following objections to three books by Faham Abdus Salam, Faiz Ahmad Taiyeb and Zia Hasan.

Fifty-nine public figures protested the decision. The High Court subsequently directed the authorities to provide the publisher with a stall, but prohibited the disputed books from being sold or displayed.

The case presented a direct test for an organisation committed to protecting literary expression. A publisher had been excluded from the country's principal book fair over the contents of books, and the judicial remedy still restricted their circulation.

Waadaa could find no public, case-specific intervention by PEN Bangladesh defending the publisher or the three authors.

A similar gap emerged in March 2023, when police detained Prothom Alo journalist Samsuzzaman Shams and proceedings were initiated against the newspaper's editor, Matiur Rahman.

International press-freedom organisations condemned the actions. A comparable public intervention by PEN Bangladesh could not be established from the records reviewed.

The organisation had spoken out in other cases.

In 2021, it condemned the death in custody of writer Mushtaq Ahmed, demanded the release of cartoonist Ahmed Kabir Kishore and protested the arrest of journalist Rozina Islam.

Those statements were issued during the presidency of Syed Manzoorul Islam.

Under Kazi Anis Ahmed, who became president in July 2021, PEN Bangladesh also criticised shortcomings in the proposed Cyber Security Act in August 2023, while acknowledging some positive elements of the draft legislation.

July 2024: A test of independence

Those questions became more pressing during the student-led uprising against Hasina in July and August 2024.

Journalists were killed or attacked, demonstrators faced violent repression and the authorities imposed an internet shutdown.

On July 19, PEN International condemned the violence and communications restrictions. The response of its Bangladesh affiliate was less visible. Writer and translator Shabnam Nadiya publicly questioned the centre's apparent silence.

In a Facebook post, she contrasted PEN International's defence of protesters and freedom of expression with the Bangladesh centre's response. Her assessment was brief: "PEN Bangladesh, gross."

Writer Hana Shams Ahmed shared the post and added: "PEN Bangladesh is a joke with Kazi Anis as its president."

Netra News reported on a restricted Facebook post in which Kazi Anis Ahmed criticised protesters in language broadly consistent with the government's portrayal of the unrest.

A separate Facebook post by Kazi Anis dated August 4, 2024, contained a more explicit denunciation.

The post alleged that the protesters' call for "non-cooperation" had provided cover for Jamaat and Islami Chhatra Shibir activists to "sow mayhem". It characterised the unrest as "planned anarchy with a political goal" and questioned whether the movement could properly be described as a peaceful student protest.

The screenshot was accompanied by a Dhaka Tribune report concerning comments attributed to student leader Nahid Islam.

Meanwhile, writing in The New York Review of Books in September 2024, Ikhtisad Ahmed criticised PEN Bangladesh's response under Kazi Anis, describing the organisation as “largely silent about Hasina's repression” and reporting that it had not answered requests for comment.

Political ties and institutional independence

Waadaa has previously examined Kazi Anis Ahmed's political commentary, his responses to allegations of Awami League sympathies and reported lobbying arrangements in Washington.

Those exchanges raise a separate question for PEN Bangladesh: what safeguards existed to ensure that the political and business relationships of its officeholders did not influence decisions about defending writers?

Kazi Anis held positions in institutions with close connections to the former government. He served as member-secretary of the international publications and translation subcommittee of Mujib100, the government-sponsored programme commemorating Sheikh Mujibur Rahman's birth centenary.

Shamsad Mortuza, who later emerged as a claimant to PEN Bangladesh's presidency, was also involved in literary initiatives associated with the centenary. Their professional association extended beyond PEN Bangladesh into the University of Liberal Arts Bangladesh, or ULAB, and a major state-sponsored cultural programme.

PEN International was asked about the centre's leadership and oversight, but neither of the two regional officials contacted by Waadaa replied.

The leadership dispute is complicated by contradictory accounts of when Kazi Anis Ahmed first became president. PEN International's historical archive identifies Syed Manzoorul Islam as president during 2018–20 and Kazi Anis as an adviser.

Records of a December 2019 annual general meeting at ULAB also distinguish between their positions. Contemporary reports identify Kazi Anis's election as president in July 2021 for the 2021–23 term.

Yet a June 2025 announcement by the group naming Mosud Mannan as president asserted that Kazi Anis had assumed the presidency in 2019 and completed two terms.

On October 16, 2026, a comment attributed to Professor Nashid Kamal appeared on Waadaa's official Facebook page in the comment section of the post on Waadaa’s report on Kazi Anis.

She alleged that Kazi Anis had persuaded then-president Farida Hossain to admit approximately 50 to 60 new members who subsequently voted for an organised slate of candidates. Nashid characterised the process as “cheating.”

Waadaa conatcted Professor Nashid but she didn’t want to elaborate on it. PEN International's historical records identify Farida as a former president and Kazi Anis as an adviser during part of the period preceding his documented 2021 election.

On July 12, an election was reported in which Shamsad Mortuza became president and Jahanara Parveen general secretary. The competing group had already announced Mosud Mannan as president.

Another question concerned ULAB's possible role in the July election. Professor Imran Rahman, who was vice-chancellor of ULAB at the time, was asked by Waadaa whether a meeting had been organised at the university following the July 2025 election that brought Shamsad Mortuza to the presidency.

Imran denied that such a meeting was organised at ULAB during his tenure.

ULAB and the limits of institutional independence

ULAB occupies a significant place in the network of relationships surrounding PEN Bangladesh. Kazi Anis Ahmed is the president of the university's Board of Trustees.

Shamsad Mortuza served as a special adviser to the board before becoming ULAB vice-chancellor in February 2026. The university's published Finance Committee membership identifies Kazi Anis as chair and Mortuza as a member.

On December 29, ULAB placed two students on disciplinary probation and warned a third over graffiti painted on campus on September 4. Some of the artwork commemorated the July uprising.

Eleven faculty members publicly objected. The university withdrew the probation on December 31, following criticism and student protests. The protests also included demands for the resignation of Vice-Chancellor Imran Rahman and changes to the Board of Trustees.

An agreement ending the protests provided for Imran to refrain from his duties pending an investigation by a committee. ULAB defended its initial disciplinary decision as a mild response to painting on campus without prior permission. It also said the graffiti would remain.

The university's treatment of the artwork subsequently changed.

At a July 2026 commemoration of the uprising, ULAB hosted graffiti and live art installations. Mortuza, by then vice-chancellor, praised the courage and sacrifice of students who had participated in the movement.

Waadaa sought an explanation from Professor Anwar Hossain about the role of Kazi Anis, as president of ULAB's Board of Trustees, in the disciplinary action against the students.

In his response, Anwar did not identify Kazi Anis by name or directly address his role in the decision. Instead, he described the “complex and emotionally charged political atmosphere” surrounding the July 2024 protests as the movement against Hasina intensified.

Anwar distanced himself from the disciplinary episode and “expressed reservations” about drawing conclusions as an “outside observer.”

—