Anu’s juggling act: Different fruits, same political basket
Anu’s juggling act: Different fruits, same political basketWaadaa Collage

Anu Muhammad and the ‘false comfort’ of political equivalence

When does criticism of a new government become a misleading comparison with the authoritarianism that preceded it?
Updated on: 

Many public intellectuals have a habit of spotting familiar patterns and declaring that history is repeating itself the moment a new government begins to disappoint them. Professor Anu Muhammad appears to have so willingly fallen into that trap.

In a Facebook post, the venerated economist described what he sees as a recurring political cycle. Those in power “engage in bullying, corruption, extortion and abuse. Public resentment grows. Meanwhile, attacks, lawsuits and mob violence against the previous rulers allow them to recover public sympathy by presenting themselves as victims,” that’s the rough translation of what he said in Bangla.

It is a recognisable warning. It is also one that requires considerably more nuances than Professor Anu gives it.

His post names neither the BNP nor the Awami League. Yet the political comparison is difficult to miss. The suggestion is that the country's present rulers risk reproducing the conditions that helped their predecessors consolidate support.

Well, that is a legitimate subject for criticism. The problem begins when an observation about recurring political behaviour obscures the enormous differences in scale and responsibility between two administrations.

The Awami League did not simply leave office after an unsuccessful term. Its government ended amid a revolution and a crackdown that the United Nations subsequently investigated as an instance of crimes against humanity. 

Bangladeshis, under Awami League were also robbed of their voting rights for 15 years and turned into a group of consumers instead of a proper citizen. 

The BNP government, by contrast, has been in office for nine months.

Yes, nine months are quite enough to expose corruption, incompetence, nepotism and abuses of authority. They are not, by themselves, evidence that two governments possess equivalent records, or even something close.

This difference is not a defence of the BNP. It is a defence of proportion.

The most troubling part of Professor Anu's argument is what it leaves unsaid.

The United Nations estimated that as many as 1,400 people were killed during the July  revolution, with the vast majority shot by security forces under Sheikh Hasina. So, its investigators found reasonable grounds to believe that the former government and its security apparatus, alongside violent Awami League elements, systematically committed grave human rights violations. 

So, that particular record cannot be compressed into a general observation about governments behaving badly. So, if history is repeating itself, which parts are repeating? The extortion? The political harassment? The denial of voting rights? The systematic killing of protesters?

These are, let’s say, not exactly interchangeable categories.

There is also a broader problem with ideological consistency. Anu is associated with Bangladesh's socialist and left-wing intellectual tradition, a movement that has often challenged governments over economic inequality, distribution of wealth, energy policy and the influence of powerful business interests.

Such criticism has a legitimate place in public debate. But left-wing intellectuals are no more immune to political selectivity than conservatives. A political theory becomes an intellectual liability when it determines the verdict before the evidence has been examined.

The temptation is to treat governments identified with the right side of the political spectrum as inherently ‘suspect’ while interpreting the failures of those nearer the left through a more forgiving historical lens. Whether Anu himself applies that double standard requires a closer examination of his public record than one Facebook post provides.

His energy activism offers another area where scrutiny is warranted. Bangladesh's energy choices involve competing questions of affordability, domestic resources, imports, environmental damage and supply security. Opposition to a project is not, by itself, proof that an alternative would work. 

Equally, supporting domestic exploration or questioning imported fuel does not establish that every proposed project is economically sound or not. The useful test is whether an intellectual's prescriptions survive examination of their costs, trade-offs and consequences. That standard should apply to Anu and his fellow campaigners as rigorously as it applies to ministers.

But there is a particular kind of irony here. Bangladesh has suffered from a political culture in which allegiance frequently substitutes for evidence. Public intellectuals ought to be the people most resistant to that habit.

The BNP government deserves scrutiny for every substantiated instance of corruption, extortion, political violence or abuse of authority. Its supporters cannot claim exemption because the previous government was worse. Nor should attacks on Awami League members be excused as a form of historical justice.

But criticism becomes less persuasive when it neglects distinctions essential to understanding the country's recent past.

Professor Anu's post identifies a real danger…that indiscriminate repression can rehabilitate discredited political forces. That is a serious argument. It does not require suggesting that Bangladesh has already returned to the political conditions of the Hasina years.

The intellectual task is to distinguish properly and Bangladesh needs critics capable of making those distinctions, especially when the government they probably oppose is in power. Because, history may repeat itself. But an intellectual should establish the true resemblance before announcing the repetition.

—

Faisal Mahmud is the Managing Editor of Daily Waadaa