Awami League’s grave mistake
Awami League’s grave mistake Waadaa Collage

The Awami League's violent road to political irrelevance

The assault on NCP supporters in London reflects the Awami League's continuing reliance on political intimidation. But violence alone cannot restore the legitimacy and influence it has lost
Updated on: 

Some reports framed what happened yesterday outside Mayfair Venue in Romford as a clash between two rival Bangladeshi political groups. It was nothing of the sort.

It was a planned, vicious attack by Awami League thugs, driven by the fanatical Bengali nationalist sentiment rooted in the Swadeshi movement that emerged during the 1905–1911 partition politics, on supporters of NCP leader Nahid Islam, one of the leading figures of Bangladesh's July 2024 revolution.

The Awami League's fanatical, thuggish brand of Bengali nationalism has caused havoc in Bangladesh for decades. It equates morality with the logic of Bengali nationalism, allowing its adherents to justify almost anything. For them, the end justifies the means. But neither rationality nor universal moral standards can justify every means employed to achieve a political objective.

I had hoped to attend yesterday's event. Inspired by the student-led movement that overthrew the Bengali nationalist dictatorship, I became a supporter of the new party, which has articulated important political positions and has yet to establish a record of wrongdoing.

I completed the online registration form using links distributed by the NCP but received no response, so I did not attend. A friend had the same experience. This suggests organisational weaknesses that may also have affected the party's security preparations. None of this, however, can justify the Awami League supporters' actions.

More than a year ago, a similar incident occurred outside SOAS University, where a group of Awami League supporters attempted to storm towards Professors Naomi Hossain and Mushtaq Khan. The incident followed an event they had hosted for Mahfuj Alam, another leading figure of the July 2024 revolution.

I was standing behind Professor Mushtaq Khan, who was behind Professor Naomi Hossain. I managed to push back one of the attackers as he tried to reach them. Fortunately, security guards and four or five police officers escorted the professors to safety inside a SOAS building.

The Awami League's intimidation may intensify following the violence in Romford, the recent unrest in Gopalganj and other incidents that its supporters regard as successes in their comeback strategy. These actions demonstrate their capacity for violence and may frighten people concerned about a possible Awami League return.

But Bangladesh is no longer the country it was in the mid-1990s or early 2000s. The Awami League and Bengali nationalism no longer dominate the production and dissemination of political narratives. The party is no longer the country's strongest political organisation, and its interpretation of the 1971 Liberation War has lost much of its former influence. The combination of political, organisational and intellectual advantages it once enjoyed has weakened.

The party retains the nationalist fervour that has long animated its politics, reinforced by Hindu nationalist influences and support from sections of India's political and intellectual establishment. But those factors are unlikely to produce a comeback resembling its earlier recoveries.

Sheikh Hasina will leave an enormous political vacuum and a damaging legacy for both the Awami League and Bangladesh. The party and its brand of Bengali nationalism have no comparable figure capable of holding them together. They remain dependent on her leadership.

At the same time, the Awami League has developed no convincing new ideas to account for its conduct in power or the political assumptions underlying it. Nor do the conditions exist for a substantial infusion of ideas from India to reverse the decline of Bengali nationalism in Bangladesh.

The answer to the Awami League's continued intimidation is not simple. But political forces in Bangladesh will resist its attempt to return, and I believe they will succeed. Violence and instability may persist in the short term, but the party's capacity to sustain its campaign will diminish as its political resources decline.

The Awami League is fighting for a cause that has lost much of its idealism and public appeal. Its efforts are likely to generate further disorder rather than rebuild political support. Without a credible moral argument capable of attracting Bangladeshis, it will struggle to recover. Once Hasina is no longer able to lead, the party is likely to disintegrate.

That decline follows a familiar pattern among political organisations built around dominant leaders who leave behind devoted followers, dysfunctional institutions and records of repression and arbitrary rule. Successors cannot simply reproduce the authority of the leader who held the organisation together. Recovery requires a period outside power, internal upheaval, new ideas and new leadership.

For now, the Awami League must be challenged intellectually through historical inquiry and counterarguments grounded in evidence, truth and reason. Its attempts to intimidate opponents or engage in political violence must also be confronted through lawful public resistance and effective policing.

The justifications offered for the Awami League's nationalist fervour and political violence are rooted, in my view, in a distorted sense of moral righteousness. Their historical origins can be traced to the emotional politics of the Swadeshi movement against the 1905 partition of Bengal.

Understanding and challenging the Bengali nationalist ideology underpinning the Awami League therefore requires a serious examination of that history: its origins, its development and the political assumptions through which it has exercised influence over Bangladesh for so long.

—

M Ahmedullah is a coordinator of Brick Lane Circle, a voluntary organization based in the London Borough of Tower Hamlets, focusing on the Bangladeshi community in the UK