Bilkis Bano
Bilkis BanoAP

'Because she is Muslim': Outrage over bail for Bilkis Bano's rapists without hearing survivor

Updated on: 

Political leaders, parliamentarians and rights organisations in India have strongly criticised the Supreme Court's decision to suspend the life sentences of two men convicted of gang-raping Bilkis Bano and murdering members of her family during the 2002 Gujarat riots, granting them bail without informing or hearing the survivor, Maktoob reports..

Bano said she learnt about the October 28 order through media reports and expressed fear for her family and her faith in the justice system.

"I still cannot believe that once again, for the second time, an order has been passed by the Supreme Court without calling me up and without hearing me. I learnt of this through press reports," she said in a statement on Monday.

"I am scared once again. For myself, my family, and my children. And I am scared of losing faith in justice, yet again," she added.

The decision has drawn criticism from leaders of the Congress, Communist Party of India (Marxist), Trinamool Congress and several Muslim and women's organisations.

Congress leader Pawan Khera said the decision had subjected Bano to further humiliation and trauma, questioning why her case had not prompted the same level of national attention as other high-profile crimes against women.

"That is the price one has to pay for being a woman, and even more so for being a Muslim," Khera said.

Recalling that Narendra Modi was Gujarat's chief minister and held the home portfolio when the crime took place, Khera said the case should have triggered a nationwide debate on women's safety, justice and accountability.

"But no outrage or action for Bilkis Bano. And why not? Because she is a Muslim in Modi's India. That is her original sin," he said.

Congress MP Syed Naseer Hussain also expressed concern, saying Bano's suffering, struggle for justice and dignity as a survivor could not be disregarded.

"Bilkis Bano was not even informed or heard before this decision was taken," he said, adding that his party stood in solidarity with her.

'The Supreme Court has delivered injustice'

CPI(M) General Secretary MA Baby described the order as "shocking and reprehensible".

He questioned why the court had granted bail to men convicted of such serious crimes while activists and undertrial prisoners continued to remain behind bars for years without trial.

Baby also recalled that the Supreme Court had previously found that the convicts had abused the legal process to secure remission from the Gujarat government in 2022.

"The Supreme Court has delivered injustice. Bilkis Bano's struggle for justice concerns every one of us. We stand with her," he said.

Jamaat-e-Islami Hind National Secretary Rahamathunnisa Abdulrazack also expressed concern, saying the decision raised serious questions about the protection of survivors' rights and public confidence in the justice system.

She said it was disturbing that an order with such significant consequences for a survivor of one of the worst crimes during the 2002 Gujarat riots had been passed without informing her or giving her an opportunity to be heard.

Abdulrazack also pointed to what she described as a disparity in the justice system, where thousands of undertrial prisoners continued to languish in jail while people convicted of heinous crimes received bail and parole.

Trinamool Congress MP Mahua Moitra questioned the decision, recalling that she and other petitioners had previously challenged the convicts' release in 2022.

Moitra said the Supreme Court had then overturned the Gujarat government's remission decision and sent the convicts back to prison.

"Today that same SC releases them without informing Bilkis. Why this travesty?" she wrote on X.

The Students Islamic Organisation of India (SIO) said a survivor's right to be heard could not be treated as an afterthought.

It also raised concerns about the vulnerability of Muslim women and the persistence of Islamophobia in India, saying no woman should have to struggle harder for justice because of her religious identity.

The National Federation of Girls Islamic Organisation (NFGIO) also condemned the decision, saying it risked deepening Bano's trauma and undermining survivors' faith in the justice system.

The organisation recalled that the 11 convicts had been welcomed with sweets and garlands by relatives and members of right-wing Hindu groups after their release in 2022, describing the celebrations as an insult to Bano's dignity.

Why the Supreme Court granted bail

A Supreme Court bench comprising Justices MM Sundresh and Prasanna B Varale suspended the life sentences of two convicts on October 28, citing the more than 17 years they had spent in prison and the severe disability of one of them.

The court said there were issues of fact and law that remained to be decided in their appeals against the Bombay High Court's May 2017 verdict upholding their convictions and life sentences.

Senior advocate Siddharth Luthra, representing the convicts, argued that one of the men had not been named in the original first information report (FIR) and had been implicated nearly three years after the incident.

Additional Solicitor General Raja Thakre opposed the bail applications.

The 2002 Gujarat riots case

Bano was five months pregnant when she was gang-raped during the anti-Muslim violence in Gujarat in March 2002.

She was fleeing her village of Randhikpur in Dahod district with her family when a Hindu mob attacked them. Seven members of her family, including her three-year-old daughter Saleha, were murdered.

In 2008, a special court in Maharashtra convicted all 11 accused of gang rape and murder and sentenced them to life imprisonment.

On August 15, 2022, the Gujarat government granted remission to all 11 convicts, who were subsequently welcomed with sweets by relatives and members of right-wing Hindu groups outside Godhra sub-jail.

However, on January 8, 2024, the Supreme Court quashed the remission, ruling that the Gujarat government did not have the authority to grant it, and ordered the convicts to return to prison.

Reacting to the latest order, Bano vowed to challenge the decision.

"I will fight this order. I must. I do this for my children, who do not deserve to live haunted by these fears and scars for the rest of their lives. I do this for my 3 year old Saleha who deserved to live, and whose memory demands justice," she said.

She added that her struggle was also for women everywhere, saying no survivor should have to spend her life fighting for justice, equality and recognition.