India calls US religious freedom panel ‘biased’ after allegations of targeting Muslims in SIR
India’s Ministry of External Affairs (MEA) on Friday dismissed allegations by a United States religious freedom panel that the Indian government was targeting Muslims through its special intensive revision (SIR) of electoral rolls, describing the panel as biased and politically motivated, Scroll reports.
The response came a day after the US Commission on International Religious Freedom (USCIRF) alleged that Indian authorities were removing Muslim citizens from voter lists, branding them as foreigners and illegally deporting them.
USCIRF head Asif Mahmood said the Indian government was “targeting Muslim citizens by removing them from voter rolls, calling them ‘foreigners’, and now illegally deporting” them.
He also cited remarks by Union Home Minister Amit Shah, who had referred to Muslims as “infiltrators” who must be expelled.
On November 2, Shah claimed that three crore voters removed during the SIR exercise were “Bangladeshi infiltrators”.
Responding to the allegations, the MEA said the commission had a “blatantly political agenda” and its assessments should not be taken seriously.
The ministry has previously accused the commission of following a pattern of issuing “biased and politically motivated assessments”.
In its 2026 annual report, USCIRF recommended that the US State Department designate India as a “country of particular concern” over what it described as “systematic, ongoing, and egregious religious freedom violations”.
The commission is an independent US government agency that monitors religious freedom worldwide and makes policy recommendations, although its recommendations are not binding.
The latest dispute follows another exchange between the two sides on November 14, when India's ambassador to the US urged the commission to introspect on its “prejudices” and “stop lecturing others” after it highlighted the case of jailed activist Sharjeel Imam.
The commission had described Imam as a Muslim man detained in India for his religious freedom advocacy. He has been in prison for more than six years in connection with the 2020 Delhi riots conspiracy case under the Unlawful Activities (Prevention) Act. The trial is yet to begin.
Controversial voter revision
The SIR exercise began in Bihar in 2025 before being extended to 12 states and Union Territories in its second phase in late 2025 and the first half of 2026. A third phase covering 19 states and Union Territories is currently underway.
The revision has drawn criticism from opposition parties and civil society groups, who fear that genuine voters could be removed from electoral rolls and that the exercise could influence election outcomes.
In May, India's Supreme Court upheld the legality of the revision but clarified that the exercise did not authorise the Election Commission to determine an individual's citizenship.
Despite the clarification, several BJP-governed states have reportedly cited the SIR to deny ration cards to people removed from electoral rolls. In some cases, police have also refused to clear passport renewals.
Nationwide protests have been held since October 2, demanding the resignation of Chief Election Commissioner Gyanesh Kumar over allegations of irregularities in the voter roll revision and concerns about the Election Commission's functioning.
