India is unlikely to extradite former prime minister Sheikh Hasina to Bangladesh, regardless of how long the legal process takes or how firmly Dhaka presses its demand, according to Dr Sreeradha Datta, a leading Indian scholar of South Asian affairs.
“Sheikh Hasina is a good friend of India. India considers her an ally, and India will never hand such a person over,” Dr Sreeradha told Daily Waadaa in an interview.
She stressed that the assessment reflected her personal understanding of Indian politics, not an official position.
“These are my personal views. I am saying what I understand as a student of politics,” she said.
A professor of international affairs at O.P. Jindal Global University who has extensively researched Bangladesh, Dr Sreeradha sees little prospect of Hasina's extradition, but believes the two neighbours have far more to lose from their continuing diplomatic impasse.
India and Bangladesh share one of the world's longest land borders. Their economies, security interests and regional connectivity are closely linked. Yet relations have remained strained since August 5, 2024, when Hasina fled to India after a mass uprising ended her 15-year rule.
Her continued political interventions from India have complicated efforts to rebuild ties with Dhaka.
The election of Prime Minister Tarique Rahman initially raised expectations of a diplomatic reset. India's foreign minister visited Dhaka following the death of former prime minister Khaleda Zia, the Speaker of the Indian Parliament attended the new government's inauguration, and New Delhi formally invited Tarique to visit.
But the proposed visit has since become uncertain. While some consular and educational services have resumed, much of the bilateral cooperation developed over previous years remains stalled.
Professor Sreeradha believes Hasina's extradition is unlikely to provide a way out of the deadlock.
“Extradition is a long process,” she said. “But even if we assume the technical and legal process could be completed quickly, does India want to extradite her? Simply put, I think it does not want to, and will not want to.”
She pointed to provisions in the bilateral extradition treaty that allow requests to be refused under specified conditions.
“Several articles in the treaty lay down specific conditions under which extradition may be refused,” she said.
Bangladesh, however, has its own political and legal reasons to continue seeking Hasina's return.
Dr Sreeradha acknowledged that Dhaka would naturally maintain its extradition demand, given the circumstances surrounding Hasina's removal from power and the allegations against her.
Professor Sreeradha was equally dismissive of the controversy surrounding Hasina's passport and the conditions under which she might return to Bangladesh.
“If she wants to go, she certainly can. She can go back the way she came,” she said. “For that, you need neither an extradition treaty nor a passport.”
She argued that while travel to a third country might require a passport, returning to one's own country was a different matter.
“All the talk we keep hearing about her passport and this and that is, to my mind, just a ruse,” she said.
“If there is an intention to return, I am sure there are ways that journey can be undertaken. But the noises around it are unnecessary and do not convey any seriousness behind it.”
In her assessment, the passport dispute has become part of a broader political exercise.
Hasina, she suggested, is using interviews, articles and videos circulated by supporters to maintain her political relevance from exile.
“She wants to keep her issue alive, and that is quite natural,” Dr Sreeradha said.
Hasina remains central to the Awami League and to party members and loyalists still in Bangladesh, she added. They need reassurance that the party's leadership remains politically relevant.
She cited recent developments in Gopalganj as an example of the party's continuing activity.
But Professor Sreeradha drew a distinction between the Awami League's surviving support base and the wider public's attitude towards its former leader.
A substantial section of Bangladesh's population, particularly younger people, continues to view Hasina negatively, she said.
That hostility, in her assessment, stems not only from the political and economic grievances accumulated during her 15 years in office but also from the violence of July 2024.
“Bangladesh has a substantial youth population, many of whom have experienced years of political and socio-economic challenges,” she said.
“The violence and attacks they endured during the July movement, however, are unlikely to fade from collective memory anytime soon.”
Those experiences, she argued, would continue to shape the younger generation's political outlook and its relationship with the state.
The more immediate diplomatic question, according to Dr Sreeradha, is which government will take the initiative to restore normal relations.
There had been a brief opening after Tarique assumed office. India's invitation to the new prime minister suggested that New Delhi was prepared to engage with Bangladesh's elected government.
But subsequent developments narrowed that opening.
Professor Sreeradha pointed to Hasina's August 5 appearance in Delhi, an event at the Foreign Correspondents' Club and the conditions later outlined by Bangladesh's foreign ministry for a prime ministerial visit.
“Taken together, it has all ended up in a very complicated place,” she said.
She questioned Dhaka's position that outstanding bilateral disputes should be resolved before Tarique visits India.
“To me, this seems a very limited point of view. When you have a problem, you come and talk,” she said.
“If you set conditions before you even talk, how is India supposed to react? Somehow it was sending a message that Dhaka was not interested.”
Her argument is that diplomacy should provide the means to resolve disagreements, rather than be made conditional on their prior settlement.
But she did not place responsibility for the impasse solely on Bangladesh.
“There is a hardening on both sides,” Dr Sreeradha said. “One of the two governments has to come forward and say: there are many outstanding issues, now let's talk.”
The question, she said, is who will make the next move.
Nor does the initiative necessarily have to come from either prime minister.
The two countries have established diplomatic mechanisms, ministers, advisers and other channels through which engagement could resume.
Professor Sreeradha said she had heard conflicting accounts about unanswered communications.
She had been told that Dhaka had not responded to several messages from New Delhi. Bangladeshi interlocutors, meanwhile, had told her that their communications on Ganges water sharing had received no response from India.
The competing accounts illustrate the difficulty of breaking the impasse.
“Apart from several bilateral mechanisms in place, there are so many advisers and ministers who can take a lead,” she said.
Both governments, she argued, would eventually have to move beyond their current positions.
“This is certainly not a sustainable phase.”
Water sharing remains one of the most consequential unresolved issues.
With the Ganges water-sharing treaty approaching a critical stage, Professor Sreeradha acknowledged Bangladesh's need for a credible commitment from India.
“An assurance on water would give Bangladesh a great deal of mental reassurance, but one has not seen that forthcoming,” she said.
She also questioned why India should continue sheltering individuals accused of serious crimes in Bangladesh, including suspects linked to the July 2024 killings and the murder of Hadi.
“I don't see any reason not to send back Hadi's killer, or some of the others that are being mentioned,” she said. “What good are they to our country?”
But she cautioned that extradition could be slow even when bilateral relations were strong.
She recalled that Bangladesh had taken considerable time to extradite Indian insurgent leaders despite the close relationship between the two governments at the time.
Dr Sreeradha favours returning to an issue-by-issue approach, under which disputes are addressed separately rather than allowing one disagreement to hold the entire relationship hostage.
India had previously advocated such an approach, she said, but the principle had gradually fallen out of use.
“If these things were taken up in a dialogue, I'm quite sure they would be settled very easily.”
The diplomatic freeze has also carried economic costs.
Professor Sreeradha pointed to Kolkata hotels that depended heavily on Bangladeshi visitors and had struggled or closed after restrictions on medical visas disrupted cross-border travel.
The effects have extended beyond tourism to businesses and services built around regular movement between the two countries.
But the economic consequences are unequal.
“India is affected too, but India's capacity to absorb a shock is much stronger,” she said.
Bangladesh's smaller economy and its dependence on cross-border links make disruptions more difficult to absorb, she suggested.
Asked whether New Delhi had interfered in Bangladesh's domestic politics during Hasina's rule, Professor Sreeradha rejected that characterisation.
India's failing, in her assessment, was different: it had largely chosen to overlook democratic shortcomings under a government it regarded as a dependable partner.
She noted the contrast between India's limited concern over political inclusivity during Hasina's tenure and the emphasis placed on that issue after her removal in 2024.
Dr Sreeradha was among the Indian academics who publicly criticised Bangladesh's flawed electoral processes during the Awami League years.
She believes New Delhi's willingness to look the other way contributed to anti-India sentiment in Bangladesh, alongside other longstanding grievances.
“The elections were far from being free and fair, but India's attitude was: the larger international community has accepted, so why should India have any different opinion?”
Her assessment points to a central difficulty in rebuilding relations: the legacy of India's close association with Hasina continues to influence how New Delhi's intentions are perceived in Bangladesh.
Yet Professor Sreeradha does not believe that legacy makes cooperation with the Tarique government impossible.
Despite the diplomatic chill, Dr Sreeradha expects India and Bangladesh to find a way back to engagement.
Geography, trade, security and regional connectivity make a prolonged breakdown in relations difficult to sustain, she argued.
“I do not envisage a situation in which we would not seek to build a partnership with an elected government,” she said.
“The relationship will gradually warm up and, over time, evolve into a friendship. But we have to begin somewhere.”
That beginning, in her view, requires one side to move beyond the present exchange of conditions and grievances and reopen a substantive dialogue.
The unresolved questions over Hasina, water sharing and the return of criminal suspects will not disappear. But neither will the interests that bind the two countries.
“Our destinies are intertwined, and working together is inevitable,” Professor Sreeradha said.
“We are wasting valuable time allowing some irritants to get in the way.”
—