Bangladesh's Nobel Peace Prize-winning Grameen Bank has become the target of apparently politically motivated violence focused on its founder (and co-Nobel laureate) Muhammad Yunus, who served as interim leader following the ouster of Prime Minister Sheikh Hasina in August 2024.
At least 35 branches of the bank have been attacked in recent weeks, raising concerns about the safety of rural communities and political violence and score-settling in Bangladesh.
For us, a father and son sharing the same name and having dedicated much of our professional lives to international development and human rights, these attacks are concerning and must end.
Although our work has taken different paths, we share commitments to protecting human dignity, defending human rights, and expanding opportunities for vulnerable people to shape their own futures. This vision is reflected in Nobel laureate economist Amartya Sen's concept of “development as freedom” and in the work of Nobel Peace Prize laureate Muhammad Yunus, who founded Grameen Bank in Bangladesh to expand access to financial services for people living in poverty, earning him the title “banker to the poor.”
For more than two decades, Step Ahead, co-founded by the elder of us, has operated a microfinance program in Thailand inspired by the Grameen Bank model. Today, Step Ahead focuses on supporting vulnerable families and children by keeping families together and providing micro-grants to improve their lives.
Our experience with microcredit shows how access to modest financial resources can help people create opportunities for themselves and their families, giving them a path out of extreme poverty.
Grameen Bank does not belong to its founder, Dr. Yunus, or any individual or family. Unlike conventional commercial banks, it is owned predominantly by its borrowers who are also its shareholders, most of whom are poor rural women. Ninety percent of the bank's ownership is allocated to its borrower-shareholders.
Attacks on Grameen Bank therefore threaten an institution in which millions of ordinary Bangladeshis have a direct financial stake.
Since its establishment in the early 1980s, Grameen Bank has challenged conventional banking practices by demonstrating that people with little or no income, traditionally excluded from accessing loans from formal financial institutions, can access credit. In the early 2000s, Grameen Bank expanded economic opportunities for people in vulnerable situations.
It launched the Struggling Members Program, providing interest-free loans to people who rely on asking others for financial assistance to survive, giving dignity to the poorest of the poor. The program enables participants to establish small businesses without rigid repayment schedules and gradually escape poverty to enter the regular Grameen Bank system. During the COVID-19 pandemic, the bank aided thousands of extremely poor families that could not make ends meet.
As the elder Quinley, I remain grateful for my relationship with Professor Yunus as a mentor and friend. Having met him several times over the past two decades, from Thailand to Indonesia and Cambodia, I can attest that he is an inspirational person whose encouragement has strengthened and motivated me to this day.
Following the uprising in Bangladesh that led to the ousting of former Prime Minister Hasina, student leaders turned to him to ask him to lead the interim government. During his tenure as interim leader, he prevented widespread political violence in Bangladesh, addressed abuses of the past, including setting up a commission to investigate enforced disappearances and torture by the security forces, and moved towards elections which were mostly free and fair.
Grameen Bank—and in particular the more recent commercial “microcredit” model—has faced criticism. The commercial microfinance sector, driven by profits rather than social good and not owned by its borrower-shareholders, has faced criticism over predatory lending practices, excessive interest rates, and coercive debt collection.
Neither of us condones such practices, but it is important to distinguish between the original Grameen Bank social-good model and its more predatory, profit-driven successors that seek to exploit rather than help the poor. Microfinance institutions must be held accountable when their activities exploit rather than empower the communities they serve.
We believe an integrated approach to microcredit has proven effective when it allows a significant governance role for its borrower-shareholders and combines access to affordable loans with mentoring, financial literacy, social protection, and training to enable borrowers, their families, and communities to build sustainable livelihoods and expand freedoms.
That model should be distinguished from the predatory and profit-driven commercial “microcredit” banks which have undermined the sector's reputation.
The Grameen Bank microfinance model, like the Aga Khan Foundation's community-based savings groups, aims to alleviate poverty by providing the poor with access to credit, savings mechanisms, and financial literacy. These models are generally forgiving to those unable to repay loans because the shareholders and leaders come from the same poor circumstances.
The commercial, exploitative “microcredit” industry turns this model on its head, exploiting the vulnerability of the poor instead.
But legitimate criticism of microcredit is different from violence directed at financial institutions and the people who depend on them—particularly Grameen Bank, which is mostly owned by its borrowers. Nor should one's opinion of Dr. Yunus, including his tenure as head of Bangladesh's interim government, make the bank he founded a legitimate target for politically motivated violence. Such violence is unacceptable.
Professor Yunus is now more than the founder of Grameen Bank but also a political figure, although he has largely retired from politics after completing his term as interim leader. His leadership and policies can and should be subject to public scrutiny and criticism.
The younger Quinley, with Fortify Rights, has documented human rights violations under the Yunus-led interim government, including the forcible return by Bangladeshi authorities of Rohingya refugees seeking safety from ongoing atrocities in Myanmar. Under the interim government, women and minorities also faced threats and intimidation, which largely went unaddressed by the authorities.
Yunus has been a vocal critic of former Prime Minister Sheikh Hasina, who is subject to an arrest warrant issued by Bangladesh's International Crimes Tribunal in connection with alleged crimes against humanity during the deadly crackdown on protesters in July and August 2024, among other crimes. But such criticism is justified, given Sheikh Hasina's repressive, corrupt, and often brutal role.
Fortify Rights has documented serious human rights violations under Hasina's government, including killings, enforced disappearances, and torture. Hasina remains in India, and Bangladesh has called for her extradition to face legal proceedings.
Some have alleged that supporters of Hasina's Awami League, whose activities are now banned in Bangladesh, are responsible for the recent attacks on Grameen Bank in an attempt to destabilize the country through targeted political violence.
Such violence by the Awami League is not limited to Bangladesh: just this week, several events in London featuring Nahid Islam, the leader of the National Citizen Party, were violently disrupted by suspected Awami League supporters.
Grameen Bank's borrowers and shareholders are predominantly rural women, alongside men, who hold diverse political views and whose livelihoods and financial security should not be jeopardized by such attacks. These mostly poor Bangladeshi women and men stand to lose the most from the attacks because they are the bank's shareholders and it is their only access to credit.
The United Nations, during a weekly press briefing, stated when asked about the attacks that all acts of violence "should be thoroughly investigated by the national authorities." The Bangladesh Nationalist Party-led government should ensure prompt, independent, and impartial investigations into the attacks on Grameen Bank and hold those responsible accountable.
Protecting Grameen Bank means protecting the rights, security, and livelihoods of millions of Bangladeshis who depend on it, as well as upholding the rule of law against politically motivated intercommunal violence that has long destabilized and traumatized Bangladesh.
—
John Quinley Jr. co-founded Step Ahead, originally a microfinance organization operating in Bangkok's largest slum community, and now a development organization supporting family-based care for children and efforts to end the institutionalization of children
His son John Quinley III is a director at Fortify Rights, an international human rights organization