This year’s Chhath Puja has become a political contest between the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) and the Trinamool Congress in Rampurhat, a largely Bengali-speaking town in West Bengal’s Birbhum district.
Caught in the middle is a Muslim-owned meat shop that was ordered to close for two days, while dozens of similar businesses were allowed to operate.
Rampurhat, a subdivisional town about 220km north-west of Kolkata near the Jharkhand border, has a small Hindi-speaking population. Chhath Puja, a festival dedicated to the worship of the Sun god and celebrated mainly in Bihar, Jharkhand and eastern Uttar Pradesh, is a major annual event for a section of the town’s residents.
As BJP leaders sought to reach out to this community during the festival, the Trinamool Congress-run municipality also took steps that have drawn criticism.
On November 13, Rampurhat Municipality chairman Soumen Bhakat issued an official notice, Memo No. 960 RM/DEV/PWD, to Noor Ali Sheikh, owner of Suraj Meat Shop. The notice directed him to keep his shop closed on November 15 and 16 for Chhath Puja. It also instructed him to cover slaughtered animals with red cloth while selling meat on other days.
Although more than 40 shops across the town sell goat meat, Sheikh was the only trader served with such a notice.
“This is the biggest festival of our Bihari community. Devotees pass in front of that shop on their way to the ghat. Blood is spilled on the road, and meat is displayed hanging outside. Religious sentiments are involved. That is why we issued a notice directing the shop to remain closed for two days,” Bhakat told The Wire.
However, as devotees travel to the ghat from different parts of the town, the order raised questions about why only a shop in a narrow lane was singled out.
Sheikh said his shop had been operating at the same location for three decades without any trouble.
“The problem is that there are nearly 30 similar meat shops along the town’s main roads, but no notice was issued to any of them. Only I received one. Even though the celebrations are scheduled for Sunday evening, I was made to shut my shop from the morning,” he told The Wire.
“I received the notice through the police station. I am surprised, but what can I do? I have to keep the shop closed,” he added.
On Sunday afternoon, Suraj Meat Shop remained closed. A new poster put up nearby by cow protection activists promoted the Go-Samman Ahwan Abhiyan, a campaign advocating respect for cows. Further along, at Gandhi Park, the Vishwa Hindu Parishad was conducting a publicity campaign around Chhath Puja.
Some Trinamool workers accused Bhakat of taking the step to appease the BJP. Rampurhat BJP MLA Dhruva Saha, meanwhile, claimed credit for the shop’s closure.
“I got that meat shop closed by speaking to the administration. It is not desirable that devotees should have to see animal carcasses on their way to the ghat. The chairman did nothing,” Saha told The Wire.
“That Trinamool chairman has not yet applied to join our party. Perhaps he is testing the waters!” he added.
However, Bhattacharya Meat Shop, located on the town’s main road, continued doing brisk business as Chhath processions passed in front of it.
Hemanta Mondal, another mutton seller, said his shop had also been allowed to remain open.
“Nobody issued me any notice. My shop is on the highway in a non-Bengali neighbourhood. Several Chhath Puja processions pass this way in the evening. But what does that have to do with a meat shop?” he told.
Kalam Sheikh, a trader whose business is beside Suraj Meat Shop, said local traders understood the implications of the move.
“The situation does not look good. To put it plainly, poor Muslims may soon find it difficult to earn a living through their businesses. When one particular community is repeatedly harassed on different pretexts, it breaks people’s spirits,” he said.
State Congress leader Milton Rashid accused the Trinamool Congress of trying to win the BJP’s favour.
“The Trinamool Congress has now been left without a guardian. So, to get into the good books of the BJP, which has become the state’s guardian, its leaders are trying to please them in the hope of gaining something in return,” he told The Wire.
Sanjib Mallick, the CPI(M) leader of the opposition in Rampurhat Municipality, said the two parties were competing over the closure of a single shop.
“We have always maintained that Rampurhat is a town with a progressive outlook,” he said. “Yet, on the occasion of Chhath Puja, the MLA and the municipal chairman are competing with each other to shut down a meat shop in a narrow lane.”
The issue has not been limited to Rampurhat. Goat meat shops were also reported closed on Sunday in several areas of Howrah, North 24 Parganas and Purba Bardhaman districts, citing Chhath Puja.
Local media reports said several meat shops across Birbhum district were also asked to remain closed on Sunday and Monday. Similar allegations emerged in Malbazar town of Jalpaiguri district, where meat shops in two wards were reportedly given the same instructions.
Reports have also highlighted the appearance of posters prohibiting the sale of land to Muslims.
---
This article was originally published in The Wire. It is republished here under special arrangement and with stylistic changes.