Bangladesh’s RMG albatross
The ready-made garment (RMG) sector has been a key contributor to Bangladesh’s transformation from an “international basket case” to a middle-income country; from “at the margin of history into the whirlpool of history”; from “the test case of development” to a “learning site”; from a “symbol of famine to a symbol of hope”. But the RMG sector has become an albatross for Bangladesh.
The infant never matured
Our RMG sector, as in other countries, developed with significant government support, including direct financial subsidies, tax concessions and measures such as preferential bonded warehouse facilities and low-interest loans. The sector also received preferential market access as a least developed country (LDC).
Fifty years on, the RMG sector still cannot survive without government support and tariff concessions from importing countries.
In the 2024-25 financial year, the sector received around 16,000 crore taka in direct financial subsidies and reduced taxes. The bulk of the current government’s 60,000 crore taka stimulus package has gone to the RMG sector.
Bangladesh Bank has instructed banks to advance loans to the sector for paying wages and to reschedule its non-performing loans, endangering the stability of a banking sector already weakened by cronies of the fallen fascist regime. RMG owners have lobbied the current government to seek a postponement of the country’s graduation from LDC status so that preferential market access continues.
Yet RMG workers have repeatedly taken to the streets demanding a living wage. As workers struggle to make ends meet amid rising living costs on a minimum wage of 12,500 taka (set in late 2023), RMG owners cry foul, despite the sector’s exports during July-October growing by 5.82% to $13.75 billion, up from $12.99 billion in the same period of FY26, according to Export Promotion Bureau data.
Bangladesh’s RMG remained an infant, as if suffering from a rare condition — sometimes called “syndrome X” — that prevents a child from developing beyond the physical size of an infant or the mental capacity of a two-year-old, a kind of Benjamin Button disorder. Yet doctors find no genetic disorder; their chromosomes are normal.
Bangladesh’s RMG, however, is not a case of “syndrome X”. Its physical growth has been phenomenal, but it has not matured.
Meteoric RMG sector growth
Bangladesh’s RMG grew physically. The sector’s rise was meteoric. In 1983-84, apparel accounted for less than 4% of total Bangladeshi exports. Within a decade, its share had grown to 60%, reaching around 84% in 2018-19. Despite pressure from competitors, Bangladesh remains the world’s second-largest garment exporter, behind China, with garments accounting for over 80% of the country’s exports.
Compare this growth with Vietnam and Cambodia, two countries regarded as Bangladesh’s competitors. As the figure below shows, based on United Nations Comtrade data, apparel’s share of total exports declined in both countries, particularly Cambodia.
We cannot compare Bangladesh’s performance using the same Comtrade data because Bangladesh stopped sharing detailed trade data with the UN in 2015. Nevertheless, both Vietnam and Cambodia have achieved significant structural transformation of their industries and exports away from a single product.
Bangladesh’s main competitor, Vietnam, moved upstream, while Bangladesh’s RMG sector remained at the lower end, producing low-cost basic garments. High-end products and higher productivity enable Vietnam to pay a higher minimum wage of about $328 (2023 data), while increasing its global market share and threatening Bangladesh’s second position.
Lower-end RMG, however, serves the sector well. These products, which economists call “inferior”, have negative income elasticity — meaning consumers switch away from them as their incomes rise and they can afford better products, while demand remains relatively stable when incomes decline. Bangladesh’s RMG sector therefore continued to grow through the 2008-09 global financial crisis and the Covid-19 pandemic.
This also helps explain why RMG exports are rising despite the worldwide increase in living costs: consumers are switching from expensive clothing to cheaper “made in Bangladesh” garments as they struggle to make ends meet.
Political economy of albatross
The sector is the country’s largest employer, directly employing around 42 lakh (4.2 million) people, of whom 60-65% are women. It indirectly supports as many as 4 crore (40 million) people, more than 25% of the country’s population. The sector is too big to fail; no government can survive its collapse.
RMG owners know this. They are like other businesspeople with normal chromosomes. They have therefore become an albatross, capturing the state to enjoy subsidies, pay lower taxes, pollute the environment and exploit workers.
One can also question who was behind Hasina’s kleptocratic fascist government’s decision to stop sharing detailed trade data with UN Comtrade. This prevents forensic investigation of trade mis-invoicing, a major mechanism for illicit transfers of funds out of the country.
Global Financial Integrity estimated that Bangladesh lost roughly $68.3 billion through trade mis-invoicing and value gaps between 2013 and 2022, including $2.7 billion to $5.9 billion in 2015 alone in trade with advanced economies.
A trillion-dollar economy?
After more than four decades of growth, Bangladesh’s garment sector still pays some of the lowest wages in the world. The minimum monthly wage stands at 12,500 taka (about $113), far below the estimated local living wage of $460.
This poses a dilemma for a government seeking to make Bangladesh a trillion-dollar economy by 2036. Can it achieve that goal when the political imperative of the RMG albatross demands that Bangladeshi labour, particularly women’s labour, remain cheap?
The creation of jobs for women has been accompanied by harsh working conditions and low wages. This weakens the economy’s potential to diversify structurally and raise living standards.
--
Emeritus Professor Anisuzzaman Chowdhury is former Special Assistant (for the Ministry of Finance) to the Chief Adviser of the Interim Government led by Professor Yunus. He held senior United Nations positions in Economic and Social Affairs in New York and Bangkok. He has written extensively on East and Southeast Asian economies, including several books. Email: a.chowdhury@westernsydney.edu.au; anis.z.chowdhury@gmail.com.
Khalid Saifullah is a statistician with years of experience working in international organisations. Email: khalidsaifullahwrites@gmail.com.